A Seoul court on Friday, November 13, dismissed Belift Lab’s 2 billion won (about $1.5 million) damages suit against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin, ruling that her claim that the HYBE label’s girl group ILLIT copied NewJeans was an expression of opinion, not a false statement of fact. The court also threw out Min’s 5 billion won countersuit against the label and a separate 500 million won suit filed by Source Music.
The 12th Civil Division of the Seoul Western District Court, presided over by Judge Kim Jin-young, delivered the first-instance ruling on Friday afternoon in a hearing that lasted about 26 minutes. Belift Lab bears the costs of its own suit, Min bears the costs of her counterclaim, and Source Music bears the costs of its claim. Both labels said they would appeal.
At the heart of the ruling was the line between fact and opinion. The court found that most of ADOR’s April 24, 2024 statement and Min’s remarks at her April 25, 2024 press conference — including that ILLIT copied NewJeans “in every area, from hair and makeup to outfits and choreography” — were subjective judgments, not assertions of concrete fact. It warned that punishing such opinions as defamation would shrink public debate and hinder the healthy growth of culture and the arts, and noted that “plagiarism” and “copy” are also used as moral and ethical criticism.
The case had been fought over four flashpoints: whether ILLIT’s team received and used NewJeans’ planning documents; how far the law protects a concept, with Belift Lab arguing that long straight hair, school uniforms and a 1990s retro mood are styles pop culture has used for decades; whether the point moves of ILLIT’s “Magnetic” lifted those of NewJeans’ “Attention” and “Ditto”; and whether Min’s remarks were unlawful and made with intent to defame, which the court answered in the negative.
The civil ruling does not end Min’s legal exposure: last month, Yongsan Police Station found defamation and business-obstruction charges warranted and referred the case to prosecutors, a step Min’s side dismissed as “only a provisional opinion of the investigative agency.” That criminal case remains open.
The verdict is a first-instance decision. With both labels vowing to appeal, the dispute that detonated K-pop’s biggest corporate feud in April 2024 is set to run on — and Min, who now leads her own label OK Records, has won the opening round.