CHOI Creative Lab has deleted H1-KEY’s music video for their new digital single “Unbelievable” and issued a statement accepting fans’ criticism, ending the AI controversy that overshadowed the group’s comeback. The agency confirmed the decision to Herald Muse on November 17, four days after the single’s release.
The agency told Herald Muse the video “was filmed with prior notice and consent from the members, and AI technology was used in the video direction and production process.” It added: “After the music video was released, we confirmed fans’ opinions on the production method, and in respect and acceptance of those opinions, we have stopped making the video public.” The agency said it would “continue to listen to fans’ opinions and strive to repay them with good music and content.”
H1-KEY released “Unbelievable” on November 13, but the video drew immediate criticism after fans noticed the members’ faces looked unnaturally rendered, with signs the footage had been heavily generated with AI. The backlash sharpened after member Hwiseo told fans on a fan chatting platform that she had seen the video only after everything had been decided, writing that the person in the video “is not me, and it’s not my opinion either,” and that she had never filmed such scenes. Her comments raised suspicions that AI had been used without the members’ consent, and fans called for the video’s removal under the hashtag #No_AI_For_H1KEY. The agency deleted the video one day after its release.
The agency also said the video was not made entirely with AI: the members filmed against chroma key backgrounds, and AI was used afterward for background compositing and in some scenes. That account sits uneasily alongside Hwiseo’s message that she filmed nothing for the video, a gap the statement does not address.
“Unbelievable” was meant to be a statement comeback for H1-KEY, their first release in about eight months since their fifth mini album “LOVECHAPTER” in March, and the group’s first attempt at electronic pop. The rollout had traded the group’s sweet “first love idols” image for leather styling and a sharper warrior concept, with leader Seoi promoting it as a one-day weathercaster on JTBC’s “Morning&” on November 10.
H1-KEY appears on SBS Life’s “The Show” on November 17. Whether the agency commissions a replacement video, and how it handles AI in future releases, remains to be seen.