A South Korean court has ordered Kim Soo-hyun and his agency Gold Medalist to pay 1.16 billion won to health supplement company FromBio, delivering the first verdict in the wave of advertiser lawsuits that followed the actor’s 2025 controversy — but the ruling stopped well short of finding that Kim breached his contract.
The Suwon District Court’s Civil Division 14, presided over by Judge Moon Hyun-ho, ruled partially in favor of FromBio, according to reports on November 13. The court ordered Kim and the other defendants to jointly pay 1,159,894,000 won, plus interest for delayed payment, and split the litigation costs with FromBio bearing 70 percent and the defendants 30 percent.
The amount is a fraction of what FromBio had sought. The company signed Kim as an advertising model in October 2024 and sued him and Gold Medalist in May 2025 for 3.96 billion won, claiming its brand image had been damaged and demanding a full refund of his modeling fee plus penalties. The court granted only part of that claim.
Crucially for Kim, the court rejected the core of FromBio’s argument. The advertiser had claimed that Kim breached the duty to maintain dignity under his advertising model contract and that the contract had therefore been terminated, entitling it to the full fee and a penalty. The court dismissed that claim in its entirety, finding that the damage to Kim’s image stemmed mainly from false information spread by a third party, which fell under the contract’s force majeure clause. What Kim’s side must return is only the portion of the model fee corresponding to the period when the advertisements did not run.
Kim’s legal team immediately pushed back on the way the ruling was reported and filed an appeal as soon as the judgment was delivered. In a statement, his representatives said it was unacceptable that a victim of false-information crimes should be ordered to return modeling fees because the consequences of that crime were treated as force majeure, adding that they would contest the decision vigorously at the appeal stage.
The ruling is the first concrete outcome in a legal pile-up that has shadowed Kim since March 2025, when Kim Se-ui, head of the YouTube channel Garosero Research Institute, alleged that Kim had dated the late actor Kim Sae-ron when she was a minor. Police later determined that the audio recordings and KakaoTalk messages Kim Se-ui presented as evidence were fabricated, and Kim Se-ui was detained and indicted on charges of spreading false information and using AI to manipulate audio. Kim himself received a non-prosecution decision on the Child Welfare Act violation allegation.
Not every advertiser case has gone against Kim. In September, he won a lawsuit brought by Swiss watch brand Mido, which had sought the return of about 570 million won in advertising fees; Mido did not appeal and the judgment became final.
Kim has also been rebuilding his public presence step by step: an advertisement shoot for an overseas clothing brand in July, an Indonesian broadcast appearance in August and a music awards presenting slot in September.
The bigger question now is what the ruling means for “Knock Off,” the Disney+ original series that has become the most important unfinished business of Kim’s career. The roughly 60 billion won production stars Kim alongside Jo Bo-ah in a story about a man whose life is upended by the 1997 Asian financial crisis and who rises to become a king of the global counterfeit market. Season 1 has been filmed and Season 2 is mostly complete, with some later filming still remaining, but the release has been on hold since the controversy erupted. Disney+ has consistently maintained that nothing has been decided about the series, even as reports surface from time to time that a release window is under discussion.
The contrast with tvN’s “Second Signal” is hard to ignore. That drama, delayed indefinitely over co-star Jo Jin-woong’s past conduct controversy, was confirmed on November 6 for a December 7 premiere, with tvN arguing that a work created by many staff members should be judged separately from one performer’s past. Disney+, which traditionally announces its next-year lineup at the end of each year, has not given “Knock Off” the same public backing, and the partial loss in the FromBio case gives the platform another reason to hesitate.
For now, the FromBio ruling changes the legal picture without settling it. The appeal will test whether the fee refund stands, a separate 2.8 billion won suit from a cosmetics brand is due for a ruling on January 22, and the fate of “Knock Off” remains the decision that will determine whether Kim’s comeback moves from public appearances to a full acting return.