TWICE member Sana is at the center of a heated debate in Japan over how she labelled a sponsored Instagram post, after fans noticed the ‘PR’ disclosure was printed in black type on a dark background — easy to miss unless the image was brightened.
Sports Kyunghyang reported on November 18 that Sana recently posted an Instagram Story holding a bottle of cosmetics serum, with the brand’s official Japanese account tagged in the image. The problem, the report said, was the advertising disclosure at the bottom: the letters ‘PR’ were set in black font against a dark background, in a form that is hard to spot without looking closely.
The post spread quickly online, and Japanese netizens split sharply over whether the labelling was deliberate or a mistake. Japan’s Consumer Affairs Agency regulates so-called stealth marketing, in which consumers cannot tell a post is an advertisement. Under the rules, a ‘PR’ disclosure must be placed where consumers can clearly see it — not in type smaller than the surrounding text or in a colour that blends into the background.
Critics argued that a star of Sana’s standing should have known better. ‘Even ordinary influencers follow the rules — for a famous celebrity like Sana to label it this way seems careless,’ one netizen wrote, according to the report. Others pointed to the contrast within the image: ‘The brand tag was white and easy to spot, but the PR label was buried in black on a dark background.’
Others defended her, noting her long history of sponsored posts. ‘Sana has posted ads plenty of times — why would she try to hide this one?’ one commenter asked. Others noted she regularly matches her text colour to the background of her Stories, suggesting the placement was likely a mistake rather than an attempt to deceive.
Sana, a Japanese national, is one of three Japanese members of TWICE, the nine-member group that debuted under JYP Entertainment in 2015 and has become one of K-pop’s biggest acts in Japan. Her large Japanese following makes her Instagram closely watched there, where influencer advertising rules have drawn increasing attention since stealth marketing was formally restricted in 2023.
Neither Sana nor JYP Entertainment had publicly addressed the debate as of publication. Whether it ends as a brief online argument or prompts clearer disclosure on future posts will depend on how the agency responds.